Table of Contents

1. Introduction
2. What Is NAP Consistency in SEO for Doctors? 
3. Why NAP Consistency Matters for Doctors in 2026
4. How Inaccurate Listings Cost You Patients: The Real-World Fallout
5. Common NAP Mistakes That Hurt Local SEO
6. How to Fix NAP Inconsistencies: A Step-by-Step Guide for Doctors
7. NAP Consistency Is More Critical for Healthcare Than Most Practices Realize
8. Why is Fact Management Important in SEO for Doctors in 2026
9. How PracticeBeat Assists Doctors with Fact Management
10. Conclusion: Start SEO for Doctors With NAP Consistency
11. FAQs: NAP Consistency in SEO for Doctors

SEO for Doctors in 2026: Why NAP Inconsistency Is Costing You Patients

In 2026,  SEO for doctors is no longer just about visibility; it’s about verifiability.

Patients don’t just search for doctors anymore. They validate them in seconds. Across Google, Maps, AI answers, voice assistants, and healthcare directories—often before your website is ever clicked, and when even one detail doesn’t match, trust breaks instantly.

This is where most medical practices are quietly losing patients.

NAP consistency, your Name, Address, and Phone number, has become one of the most overlooked yet high-impact pillars of SEO for doctors. What once felt like “basic listing hygiene” is now a core trust signal that directly influences Google Local Pack rankings, AI-driven recommendations, voice search results, and patient decision-making.

In an era where healthcare searches fall under Google’s strict YMYL standards, inaccurate or fragmented listings don’t just hurt rankings—they signal risk. To algorithms. And to patients.

At PracticeBeat, we see this daily: clinically excellent practices with strong reputations being filtered out of local search results because their digital facts don’t align. A missing suite number. An outdated phone line. Duplicate profiles splitting authority.

This blog by Practiceebeat experts breaks down why NAP consistency is mission-critical for medical practices in 2026, how inaccurate listings are costing you real patients, and what it takes to build a single, trusted source of truth that search engines—and patients—can rely on.

Because in modern medical SEO, being good isn’t enough. You have to be consistently findable, verifiable, and trusted.

Is Your Practice AI-Ready or Is Your Data Driving Patients to Competitors?

In 2026, SEO for doctors has shifted from "keywords" to "verified facts."  AI-driven search engines no longer just scan your website; they cross-reference your Name, Address, and Phone number (NAP) across the entire web to decide if you are trustworthy.

If your digital data isn’t perfectly synced, your practice is effectively invisible to the newest wave of AI search.

Claim Your FREE Practice Growth Audit. We will diagnose your digital "Source of Truth," identify hidden revenue leaks, and show you exactly how to dominate AI-driven healthcare search.

Claim Your Free $2,500 AI-Ready Audit

What Is NAP Consistency in SEO for Doctors? 

In 2026, NAP consistency refers to the exact uniformity of a business’s Name, Address, and Phone number across all online platforms. It is a foundational local SEO signal that signals to search engines that your practice is legitimate, active, and trustworthy. 

NAP stands for:

• Name: Your official practice or provider name. It shows how your practice or clinic is listed — e.g., “Dr. XYZ Family Medicine”)  It should be identical everywhere.
• Address: Your physical location, including the street, city, state, and zip code. Even slight variations—like "Suite 200" vs. "Ste 200"—should be standardized to match your Google Business Profile.
• Phone number: Your primary local contact number. Avoid using different tracking or department numbers in public listings unless they are secondary to your main line. 

Inconsistent NAP data can push you out of the Local 3-Pack, where most clicks occur. Every minor NAP variation dilutes your presence, and over time, these discrepancies accumulate, undermining how search engines perceive your authority and relevance.

How to Maintain Consistency

• Perform a NAP Audit: Use tools like Moz Local, BrightLocal, or Yext to scan the web and identify conflicting listings.
• Create a "Source of Truth": Maintain a master spreadsheet with your standard NAP format to use whenever you create a new profile.
• Claim Your Listings: Take ownership of profiles across major health and business directories to prevent third parties from suggesting incorrect edits.
• Use Schema Markup: Embed Local Business Schema on your website to provide search engines with a clear, structured version of your correct data. 

Get Your 2026 NAP Health Score: Is Your Data Driving Patients Away?

Run a Complimentary 2026 Assessment to see if your practice meets the new standards for AI search and identify the "data leaks" hurting your Local Pack rankings instantly.

Get Your Free Assessment Score

Why NAP Consistency Matters for Doctors in 2026

Local search has become hyper-competitive. Today’s patients are not just searching for a “dermatologist”—they’re searching for a dermatologist near me with availability now. If your practice can’t be found quickly and accurately, patients will click on a competitor who can. Here’s why NAP consistency is foundational to that process:

• Google Local Pack Dominance: Google's local algorithm uses NAP data to verify a clinic’s legitimacy. Inconsistent details are flagged as "unreliable," causing practices to drop out of the Local 3-Pack—the top results on Google Maps that receive the most clicks.
• Building Patient Trust (E-E-A-T): In healthcare, "Trustworthiness" is a core pillar of Google's E-E-A-T guidelines. Conflicting contact details trigger doubt; 80% of consumers lose trust in a local business if they find inconsistent information online.
• Voice & AI Search Readiness: In 2026, AI-driven assistants (like those from Apple or Google) rely on structured business data to provide voice directions or call a provider. Fragmented NAP data prevents these tools from correctly identifying your practice as the best local option.
• Operational Revenue Loss: Inaccurate listings lead to "leaky" revenue cycles. Patients who call a disconnected number or drive to a former office location are often deterred from continuing their search and booking with a more "organized" competitor. 

Common 2026 Pitfalls for Medical Practices

• Individual vs. Practice Listings: Conflict between an individual doctor's name and the overall clinic's name across different platforms.
• Legacy Data from Moves: Outdated addresses from previous relocations that remain active on third-party healthcare sites like Healthgrades or Zocdoc.
• Minor Formatting Errors: Even slight variations, such as "Suite 100" vs. "#100," can dilute your "authority signals" and confuse search algorithms. 

Strategic Steps for Doctors

1. Establish a "Canonical" NAP: Choose a single, exact format for your name, address, and phone number as your master reference.
2. Audit Healthcare-Specific Directories: Ensure your data matches across medical-specific portals such as WebMD Care, Vitals, and Doximity.
3. Implement Schema Markup: Use structured data on your practice's website to tell search engines exactly which details are current and authoritative.
4. Use Automation for Updates: Leverage listing management software like Moz Local, BrightLocal, or Yext to synchronize changes across 80+ platforms simultaneously.

In 2026, NAP consistency (Name, Address, Phone number) is a critical survival factor for medical practices. As search engines and patients demand higher reliability, inaccurate listings are increasingly directly linked to lost revenue and patient leakage. 

SEO keywords are dead; verified facts are the new currency of 2026.

If Google Gemini can't verify your location, it won't recommend your practice—period.

Claim the FREE Market Shifter Report ($2,500 value), which gives you the blueprint to synchronize your digital footprint and dominate AI-driven search results. 

See your market score and secure your top-tier ranking.

Get My Market Shifter Report

How Inaccurate Listings Cost You Patients: The Real-World Fallout

It’s easy to think that inaccurate listings are just a technical SEO issue — something only search engine nerds worry about. But the ramifications go far beyond algorithms. Here’s how inaccurate NAP data translates into real business loss:

1. Missed Calls and Patients Who Never Show Up

If a potential patient finds your outdated phone number on one directory and calls it — only to get a disconnected line — they’re unlikely to search for your practice again. Studies show that when users encounter incorrect business information online, a significant percentage will abandon the business entirely.

Similarly, if your address is listed without a suite number or contains a typo, patients may arrive at the wrong location — leading to frustration, wasted time, and loss of trust. This is especially catastrophic in healthcare, where first impressions matter.

2. Lost Credibility and Damaged Trust

Healthcare is built on trust. One inconsistent listing might seem trivial, but patients who find inconsistent details — “Different number here, different address there” — may question your professionalism. In fact, a majority of consumers lose trust in a business due to inaccurate listings.

This erosion of trust can lead a patient to book with a competitor who presents a cleaner, more consistent digital footprint.

3. Fragmented Online Presence and Duplicate Listings

Inconsistent NAP data can produce duplicate listings — where the same clinic appears in multiple directories with slightly different details. These duplicates split your reviews, confuse search engines, and weaken your SEO signals. Over time, that means fewer visibility signals and fewer chances for patients to find and contact you.

4. Reduced Local Visibility in Voice Search and Maps

Voice search usage continues to grow — patients increasingly use Siri, Alexa, or Google Assistant to find doctors. These systems rely on accurate NAP details to give reliable answers. Inconsistent data can result in your practice being excluded from voice search results or represented incorrectly.

Similarly, map results — like Google Maps listings — depend heavily on consistent NAP signals. Any discrepancies can hurt your positioning on these platforms, lowering the chances of appointment bookings.

Don't let a "Suite #" typo drive your patients to a competitor.

Google Gemini and voice assistants only recommend practices they can verify with 100% certainty.

Our Free 2026 NAP Consistency Assessment pinpoints every outdated address and broken phone number currently hurting your rankings. Stop the data leaks and start capturing more high-value appointments today.

Run My Free NAP Assessment

Common NAP Mistakes That Hurt Local SEO

In 2026, NAP (Name, Address, Phone number) consistency remains a high-priority ranking factor for medical practices. Even minor discrepancies can signal unreliability to Google’s AI-driven local search algorithms, leading to lower visibility and lost patient trust. 

Some of the most frequent NAP issues we see in healthcare involve simple errors — but their impact is massive:

❌ Practice Name Variations

• “Dr. XYZ Cardiology.”
• “Dr XYZ Heart & Vascular”
• “Northside Medical Dr.”

Practice Name variations are one of the most common ways doctors inadvertently sabotage their local SEO. This creates a "NAP conflict" that can hide a clinic from the Google Local Pack.

Google gives "authority" to a specific business name. Using different names splits SEO power, making it harder to rank higher than a competitor with one strong name. Your best bet is to select a single, exact version of the name as the official digital identity.

❌ Address Formatting Differences

• “Street” vs. “St.”
• Missing suite or floor numbers
• Different city spelling

Address formatting differences are more than just cosmetic errors; they are data discrepancies that can prevent your practice from appearing in high-intent "near me" searches. Google’s algorithms prioritize "identical matches" to confirm a business's physical location.

Variations as minor as "Ste 200" vs. "Suite 200" or missing suite numbers entirely can weaken your local presence and lower your practice's "confidence score," which can drop you out of the Local 3-Pack. In 2026, exact address data is essential for accurate voice search results and GPS navigation.

Pick one and stick to it universally. 

❌ Multiple Phone Numbers Across Platforms

Using multiple "call tracking" numbers across various directories instead of one consistent primary line can prevent search engines from verifying your identity.

Google and AI search engines use your phone number as a unique "fingerprint." If Google sees one number on your website, another on Healthgrades, and a third on Yelp, it may conclude the business is unverified or illegitimate, leading to a drop in Local Pack rankings. 

Designate one local landline as your "canonical" number for all public directory listings. 

❌ Outdated Listings

As search engines transition to AI-driven models that prioritize verified, single-source-of-truth answers, having fragmented or conflicting profiles on the web is increasingly penalized.

Common Examples of Outdated Listing:

• Old Address: A listing for your practice at a location you moved out of two years ago.
• Former Staff: Profiles for doctors or partners who have retired or left the practice.
• Disconnected Phone Numbers: Old lines that are no longer in service.
• Legacy Branding: Listings showing a former practice name before a merger or rebranding.

Outdated listings lead to "ghost" calls to disconnected lines or to patients driving to former locations, often resulting in negative reviews that further damage your reputation and rankings.

❌ Duplicate Listings

A duplicate listing is the existence of multiple active profiles for the same practice or location on the same platform (e.g.,  two different Google Business Profiles for the same office).

Maintaining multiple Google Business Profiles for the same location violates Google's terms of service and can result in the suspension of your legitimate profile, effectively removing you from search results.

Duplicates split your "Review Power." Instead of one profile with 100 five-star reviews, you might have two profiles with 50 reviews each, making you look less authoritative than a competitor with one strong profile. 

Is your practice data healthy, or is a "digital leak" making you invisible?

In 2026, AI search engines ignore providers with even minor NAP errors.

Run your Free NAP Consistency Assessment to diagnose the hidden listing conflicts that are blocking new patients from finding your clinic. Get your total practice health score in seconds.

Scan Your Practice Now

How to Fix NAP Inconsistencies: A Step-by-Step Guide for Doctors

Now that you understand why NAP consistency matters, let’s walk through how to fix this issue effectively.

In 2026, fixing NAP (Name, Address, Phone number) inconsistencies is the highest-ROI local SEO activity for medical practices. With AI search engines now prioritizing "verified" data over unverified mentions, follow this structured guide to audit and repair your digital footprint.

Step 1: Create Your "Canonical" Master Sheet

Before editing anything, you must establish a single "Source of Truth." Open a spreadsheet and document your official 2026 data exactly as it appears on your legal documents and office signage.

• Exact Name: (e.g., Green Valley Pediatrics vs. Green Valley Pediatrics, P.C.)
• Standardized Address: Use the USPS Zip Code Lookup to find the official format (e.g., "Suite" vs "Ste").
• Primary Local Phone: Use a local area code, not a toll-free or tracking number.

Step 2: Clean Up Your "Google Business Profile" (GBP)

As the primary driver of local SEO, your GBP must be the first point of correction.

1. Log in to your Google Business Profile.
2. Update your info to match your Master Sheet exactly.
3. Audit for Duplicates: Search Google Maps for your practice name and address. If you find multiple pins for the exact location, use the "Suggest an edit" tool to select "Close or remove" > "Duplicate of another place."

Step 3: Sync High-Authority Medical Directories

In 2026, search algorithms heavily weigh "niche citations." If your information on health-specific sites doesn't match your website, your trust score drops.

1. Healthgrades: Claim your provider and practice profiles to update office hours and locations.
2. Doximity: Ensure your residency and board certifications are linked to the correct 2026 office address.
3. WebMD/Vitals: Check these legacy sites, as they often rank highly in search results despite having older data.

Step 4: Automate the "Long Tail" of Citations

There are hundreds of smaller directories (Yelp, YellowPages, Bing, etc.). Manually fixing these is inefficient.

1. Use a listing management tool like Moz Local, BrightLocal, or Yext.
2. Upload your Master Sheet. These tools will "push" your correct 2026 data to dozens of platforms simultaneously and automatically "lock" them so third parties can't change them back.

Step 5: Implement Structured Schema Markup on Your Website

Tell search engines exactly which data is correct by using the LocalBusiness Schema.

1. Use a tool like the Merkle Schema Generator to create code for your practice.
2. Embed the code into the header of your medical website. This provides a machine-readable version of your NAP that search bots use to verify your identity.

Step 6: Verify Insurance Portals

A common 2026 SEO "leak" occurs when a doctor’s listing on UnitedHealthcare or Aetna lists an old office.

1. Log in to your provider portals.
2. Ensure your 2026 location matches the one on your Google listing. Google often crawls these high-trust databases to verify a doctor's legitimacy.

Summary Checklist for 2026

• Is the name the same on my website and Google?
• Does my address include the same Suite/Ste format everywhere?
• Have I merged all duplicate Google Maps pins?
• Is my local phone number (not a tracking number) listed as "Primary"?
• Is Schema markup active on my Contact page?

Stop letting competitors with lower-quality care outrank you simply because their data is cleaner.

Visibility belongs to the most consistent provider, not just the best one.

Book your Free Strategy Call for a custom blueprint on how to synchronize your NAP data and dominate the Local 3-Pack. We’ll show you exactly how to become the authoritative "Source of Truth" in your medical niche.

Get My Local Dominance Plan

NAP Consistency Is More Critical for Healthcare Than Most Practices Realize

In 2026, NAP consistency (Name, Address, Phone number) is a specialized trust signal for healthcare that carries higher stakes than in almost any other industry. Because medical searches fall under Google’s "Your Money or Your Life" (YMYL) classification, search engines apply stricter standards for accuracy and reliability. 

1. Verification of Medical Legitimacy

Search engines use NAP data to cross-reference your practice across government databases, medical boards, and insurance portals. Inconsistent details can trigger "red flags" in the algorithm, suggesting your practice is unverified or potentially fraudulent, which results in a significant drop in Google Local Pack rankings. 

2. High Patient Verification Rates

Unlike retail, healthcare patients are highly risk-averse. Over 74% of patients now verify a provider’s NAP information across multiple sites before booking an appointment. If they find conflicting data—such as different phone numbers on Healthgrades versus your own website—they are likely to abandon the search due to a lack of professional trust. 

3. Impact on Patient Safety

Inaccurate medical listings are a safety risk. For urgent care, pediatrics, or specialized surgery, a wrong address can lead to critical delays in care. In 2026, Google’s AI models increasingly prioritize "Safe Care" results, which means practices with verified, consistent physical addresses are more likely to be featured in emergency-related searches. 

4. Fragmented Digital Identities

Healthcare practices often face unique NAP challenges that other businesses do not:

• Multiple Locations: Clinics with numerous satellite offices often have "leaking" data, with old addresses persisting in legacy directories.
• Provider vs. Group: Patients often search for specific doctors (e.g., "Dr. Jane Smith") rather than the clinic name. Without a synchronized Fact Management strategy, these individual profiles can compete with and suppress the leading clinic’s listing. 

5. Critical Trust & E-E-A-T Signal

In 2026, "Trust" is the most weighted component of Google’s E-E-A-T (Experience, Expertise, Authoritativeness, and Trustworthiness) criteria for medical providers. NAP consistency is the foundational proof of a practice’s real-world existence; without it, even high-quality medical content may fail to rank because the underlying business entity is viewed as unreliable

The healthcare journey often begins online — with a local search, a directory listing, or a voice search query. If the contact details don’t match, patients lose trust. If the results aren’t accurate, patients go elsewhere. In fast-moving local markets in 2026, your NAP accuracy isn’t just a ranking factor — it’s a patient acquisition strategy.

Is Inconsistent Data Bleeding Your Bottom Line?

In the high-stakes SEO landscape of 2026, a single "unverified" fact can disqualify your practice from the top search results. Don’t leave your patient acquisition to chance.

Schedule your FREE NAP Strategy Consultation to get a expert's-eye view of your digital footprint. In this brief call, we will:

• Identify the specific data discrepancies hurting your Local Pack ranking.

• Map out a strategy to align your practice with Google’s 2026 E-E-A-T standards.

• Show you exactly how automated Fact Management can save your staff hours of manual work.

Schedule Your Free Consultation

Why is Fact Management Important in SEO for Doctors in 2026

In 2026, fact management has superseded traditional SEO as the most critical component of a doctor's digital presence. While SEO focuses on keywords, Fact Management ensures that every AI model, search engine, and voice assistant has the correct "source of truth" regarding your medical practice.

The Importance of Fact Management in 2026

• Reliable AI Search: In 2026, AI-driven search engines, such as those powered by Google's Gemini, prioritize facts over websites. Inaccurate information, such as differing office hours across platforms, may cause AI tools to exclude a practice from search results.
• Zero-Click Searches: Many patients now find the needed information, like phone numbers or addresses, directly on search result pages. Incorrect facts can prevent conversions.
• E-E-A-T Compliance: Google's E-E-A-T (Experience, Expertise, Authoritativeness, and Trustworthiness) standards for healthcare are crucial. Inconsistent data signals low trustworthiness and can negatively affect a practice's search rankings.
• Accurate Voice Search: Fact Management ensures that voice commands, such as "call my dermatologist" or "give me directions to the clinic," connect patients to the correct location.

How PracticeBeat Assists Doctors with Fact Management

PracticeBeat is a healthcare growth platform designed for medical data management.

1. Centralized "Source of Truth."

PracticeBeat acts as a central hub. It allows practices to update facts once in the PracticeBeat dashboard. The platform then distributes this data, including provider credentials, insurance accepted, and office hours, across the digital ecosystem.

2. Automated Citation Synchronization

The platform continuously audits and corrects inaccurate data across major directories, including Healthgrades, WebMD, and Google Business Profile. This prevents outdated information from resurfacing.

3. Duplicate Listing Management

PracticeBeat uses automated tools to identify and merge duplicate listings for individual doctors and the practice. This ensures that patient reviews and search rankings are concentrated on a single, authoritative profile.

4. Healthcare-Specific Fact Fields

PracticeBeat manages specific healthcare facts, such as:

• Insurance Participation: Keeping accepted plans up to date to appear in relevant searches.
• Provider NPI and Bio Data: Synchronizing credentials to improve the E-E-A-T score.
• Real-Time Appointment Availability: Linking scheduling software directly to search results.

5. Performance Monitoring

PracticeBeat offers "Market Share" reports to show how Fact Management efforts translate into rankings compared to competitors. This allows practices to adapt their strategies to current search trends.

By using a specialized platform like PracticeBeat, medical practices transition from passive SEO to active Fact Management to maintain a competitive edge in 2026.

Stop Chasing Algorithms. Start Capturing Patients.

Manual listing updates and fragmented data are the "silent killers" of medical practice growth. In 2026, you can’t afford to be a "maybe" in Google’s eyes.

Book your 15-minute PracticeBeat Demo to see our Fact Management system in action. We’ll show you how to automate your NAP consistency, eliminate duplicate listings, and build a "Source of Truth" that turns AI search into your #1 patient referral source.

Schedule Your Free Demo Today!

Conclusion: Start SEO for Doctors With NAP Consistency

In 2026, SEO for doctors is no longer about chasing keywords or publishing more blogs. It’s about trust, verification, and visibility at the exact moment a patient is ready to book care. And nothing undermines that faster than inconsistent NAP data.

Every outdated address, duplicate listing, or mismatched phone number quietly tells Google, AI systems, and patients that your practice is unreliable—even if your clinical care is exceptional. The result? Fewer Local Pack rankings, missed calls, broken directions, lost trust, and patients choosing a competitor who simply “looked easier to find.”

NAP consistency is no longer SEO hygiene. It is a patient acquisition infrastructure.

This is where most practices fall behind—and where PracticeBeat becomes the difference.

At PracticeBeat, we don’t treat NAP cleanup as a one-time task. We build Fact Management systems that continuously verify, synchronize, and protect your practice’s digital identity across Google, healthcare directories, insurance portals, AI search engines, and voice assistants.

✔ One verified source of truth
✔ No duplicate listings
✔ No hidden revenue leaks
✔ Full alignment with SEO for doctors in 2026

If your practice is losing patients before they ever reach your website, the problem isn’t your care—it’s your data.

Build Your Patient Acquisition Engine With PracticeBeat

Don’t let something as simple as inconsistent contact information hold your practice back. In 2026, NAP consistency is SEO hygiene — and patient experience — done right.

Book your FREE PracticeBeat Demo and see how leading practices clean up NAP issues, dominate local search, and convert intent into appointments.

Stay Consistent. Stay Visible. Start with PracticeBeat

FAQs: NAP Consistency in SEO for Doctors

1. What is NAP consistency in SEO for doctors?

NAP consistency refers to keeping your practice name, address, and phone number identical across all online platforms, including Google Business Profile, healthcare directories, maps, and AI-driven search tools. In local SEO for doctors, even minor inconsistencies—such as “Suite” vs. “Ste”—can weaken trust signals and reduce visibility in Google’s Local Pack and Maps results.

2. How does inaccurate NAP data affect Google Local Pack rankings?

Google uses NAP data to verify a medical practice’s legitimacy. Inconsistent or conflicting listings signal unreliability and cause your practice to drop out of the Local 3-Pack, where most high-intent patient clicks occur. In 2026, Google’s AI-driven local algorithms heavily prioritize verified, consistent business data for healthcare providers.

3. Why is NAP consistency more important for healthcare than other industries?

Healthcare searches fall under Google’s YMYL (Your Money or Your Life) category, which applies stricter standards for accuracy and trust. Inaccurate listings can impact patient safety, E-E-A-T scores, and AI recommendations, making NAP consistency a critical ranking and trust factor for doctors and clinics.

4. How does NAP consistency impact voice search and AI search results?

Voice assistants and AI search engines rely on structured, verified facts—not websites alone. If your NAP data is inconsistent, voice search tools may skip your practice entirely or provide incorrect directions or phone numbers. Accurate fact management ensures your practice appears in “near me” voice searches and AI-generated answers.

5. How does PracticeBeat help doctors maintain NAP consistency at scale?

PracticeBeat centralizes fact management for medical practices, acting as a single source of truth for NAP data, provider credentials, office hours, and insurance details. Our platform continuously audits, syncs, and corrects listings across Google Business Profile, healthcare directories, and AI-driven search ecosystems—preventing duplicates and outdated data from resurfacing.

6. Is NAP consistency still relevant if my website is well-optimized?

Yes—and increasingly so. Medical website development and SEO for doctors cannot compensate for inaccurate listings. In 2026, search engines validate your website content against external facts. If your NAP data doesn’t match across the web, even a high-performing website may struggle to rank locally or convert patients.